The stories about which group of people settled in Giethoorn first contradict each other, but it is more likely that there was overlap. As a result it is not possible to establish exactly who could first call themselves a native of Giethoorn (a Gieterse), and so we name both as the first residents of our village. Some stories say that Flagellants were the first to settle in this area towards the end of the 13th century (supported by archive references that mention the year 1291). The other account concerns a group of poor people who no longer had a place in their original community.
Because of exponential population growth in the fertile period, there was not enough food in the overcrowded communities to feed everyone. The worst off were of course the victims of this and looked for remote places to settle. That is how a group of poor people ended up in Giethoorn, where, on the recommendation of the prefect of Vollenhove, they were admitted conditionally by the bishop.